Self-defeatism
Posted by Kaleidoscope on December 8, 2005
Written by: Tantalize
In the morning when I start teaching my classes, I come across looks of defeat on many of my students’ faces. One is only 19, married, already a mother of one, and soon to be divorced. She mannequins anguish and a flinching attempt at smiling when I ask her how she is each and every day. Another student is a Jahra resident Bedouin. She knows her marriage will be out of her choosing as soon as she graduates. It will be unwillingly to someone from her tribe and most likely to her first cousin. Her face reads despair. Many of the female students seem careless with little enthusiasm because they sense that their fates have been sealed. They’ve been sealed by a projected time in which Islam and local traditions have already outlined, potentially manufactured, and guided their lives before they have even started. They have been contained by sets of uncontested customs in which they have become a menacing reality. Suicide is no option since it is sinful. Living out their deceptive lives holds more hope but while hopelessly holding on to sets of ideals they have no say in creating. This is what I see on a daily basis and on a semester routine.
A male student openly flaunts a facial mix of disinterest and discontent. He is not exhausted from school, but more tired of wanting to continue educating his brain because he thinks what he is learning is futile. He will get the job he wants due to wasta (connections) in a field totally unconnected to his present major and unconnected to what he may personally desire. His future is predestined by an over-nurturing family which has become his immediate religion: mafia-wasta.
The American teachers in the faculty room are slowly being sapped as well. They are falling to the cancer of this Kuwaiti-self-inclined-defeatism. They are put in a catch-22. They have been hired to strenuously teach and implement a language and culture from a place thousands of miles away; to a people who show more interest in its lifestyle than in its rules. The expats, as they call themselves, are spun between the strict textbook regulations they are expected to adhere to and mixed messages from the administration. They are flooded with conflicting taboo subject matters in the books, that the Kuwaiti faculty has reviewed and accepted but haphazardly enforces. Having many of the students come deliberately late, sugarcoating their guilt with dozens of “inshallas”, and scapegoating others but rarely themselves for problems self-bestowed boils the teachers’ sense of impeccability, decorum and time management. Thus, these foreign teachers are unknowingly becoming prey to defeatism, too. They are in a sense defeating themselves because they eventually and subconsciously accept and become engrossed by a greater and more societal self-defeatism.
When it comes to the general Kuwaiti faculty, they are the epitome of uselessness. They know they will get paid at the end of the month and can never be fired from a government position, that is a clause in the country’s constitution. Therefore, they cut classes here and there, utilize wasta in their favor, subject students to authoritarian style of learning, make them feel insignificant to eventually help them pass with ease. This is done after the students had been ridden through a labyrinth of hell. Conclusively, the faculty gives off the same defeatism to the next generation of citizens.
What appears to be magnanimous amounts of manual workers at fixing and cleaning after the students on campus have the heaviest sense of defeatism. Some of these Asian workers are as old as grandparents but they cater to people a fraction of their age, in an environment where teachers are supposedly teaching and enforcing human equality and respect. And all the while Asians are calling for prayer on megaphones from surrounding mosques. The students, on the other hand, walk past these workers as if they are invisible. Some of the faculty uses them to fetch them snacks from a cafeteria few meters away, while other workers are used to photocopy and deliver papers, when their sole job requirement is to clean.
As I leave work, I am thrusted by animalism and lack of respect on the streets by drivers who deserve much less than the type of cars they are driving. Their sense of civility is pathetic and their self-respect is as unendorsing. Some seem oblivious to being killed as they drive like maniacs. The faces they wear are evidence of that. The makes of cars they drive are not. They speed in carelessness just to gain a few meters ahead of others. They know there are traffic jams ahead of them but they race anyhow. Some seem to beg to be put out of their misery by having someone ram them. I truly believe that they think they are invincible and that Allah (God) will parcel them quickly to heaven if they ever do get killed. So, they don’t fear dying. Or, they may just want someone to kill them out of pity; to put them out of their own nihilistic misery.
As I approach home, I then wonder if there is any correlation to how the heaviest lunch meals are eaten and how much liban (buttermilk) is drunk during the hottest times of the day. I ponder if there is a connection to how people sleep in the afternoons and how they feel drowsy the rest of the day with how they are incompetent the next day when they head to work or school. It’s a vicious cycle of self-annihilation.
© COPYRIGHT TANTALIZE 2005

December 8, 2005 at 12:05 pm
strong.. and it does touch on certain facts, like boys and girls being worn out before they even do anything.. they dont give themselves the credit
but i strongly, strongly disagree with the reasonings.. i reckon it is becoz they dont adopt the real q8i ways u speak of, but rather take them at face value .. so its not really about social/cultural “constraints”
just as they take at face value their education, as u say not even caring to employ it later as a tool to get what they want from their lives.. its more individualistic, they need a slap on the face (these ppl exist everywhere regardless of environment)
the kuwaiti staff is well-described, BUT i just HAVE to say this: some of them r just misunderstood - i know that to be so true its not up for discussion heh
the piece is v. strong, yet very ambitious in simplifying complex relationships
December 8, 2005 at 3:19 pm
You’re very perceptive to say that many in Kuwait are fascinated with the freedom American/ British culture offers (booze, weed, sex, a dabble in agnosticism perhaps) but care very little for their respect for the law, their work ethics, their genuine belief in democracy and human rights.
I like the mafia-wasta bit as well. Despite all our fashion sense, our western education, our self-proclaimed “open-mindedness”, we still think as tribe members, unfortunately.
And as for your sympathy with Asian menial laborers, this is not the first time you have written about this. You seem to care alot about the way they are treated in Kuwait. Why don’t you join the Red Crescent Society and do some volunteer work for Asian laborers? As a person who loves volunteer work, I believe the joy one gets from giving may pull you out of your dark mood!
(Either that, or a juicy night with one of those 20yr olds you so dearly love ;-))
December 8, 2005 at 4:10 pm
This is one of my favourite pieces you’ve written so far. It’s well constructed and flows smoothly from one topic to the next. Reading it was a pleasure, thank you.
December 8, 2005 at 6:17 pm
Temetwir: Thanks. That is what may be the problem. There isn’t much individuality because they have not been exposed to that. It’s been more communal than anything else. They need more than just a slap across the face. They need to be injected with high doses of Turkish coffee. lol.
I never used all faculty or students. There are cases of incredible teachers and students. No doubt about that. I was just generalizing.
Mushmushi: Maybe I’ll have to volunteer my free time to those 20 year olds you seem to persistently think I adore. And what may seem dark to one person can be light to another. ;^)
McArabian: I am very appreciative. It’s been a while since you’ve been here.
December 8, 2005 at 6:59 pm
The despondent mood of this piece says: it’s almost the end of the semester. We’re all tired out.
I knew a very unique Bedouin girl once. Proactive; enthusiastic, independent - and scornful of her brother who did not do his duties towards the family. But she did not drive; her mother did not allow it.
Her dream was to marry an American Muslim; She ended up marrying a Bedouin from her tribe who was less educated than she but very open to her continuing her graduate studies. She is now an even more independent and happy mother.
Don’t feel too sorry for the girls. They would feel even sorrier had they not married at that young age.
I must say that enthusiasm is infectious: both from a teacher and a boss. If you are enthusiastic, and dynamic in your approach, you give those students a lift. You make them look forward to coming to class and enjoy learning.
And an enthusiastic proactive manager/supervisor can do wonders for the morale of dejected/bored employees.
As for the traffic jams and labourers: There should be more women with strict principles in government and parliament to clean up this country.
I would allocate a good portion of the supposed revenue the government doesn’t know how to use, to sending those Asians & Arab workers back home by plane loads upon plane loads. Too many for our own good.
And then, perhaps those dejected Kuwaiti employees would get off their rear ends and make their own tea, coffee and get their own snacks.
They would actually get up and photocopy papers instead of calling Babu and wait 5 minutes until he comes to do the job.
They would start to get creative on the job instead of just gossiping and tearing other people apart; they would be preparing and reading reports instead of reading newspapers; they would use the Internet and information technology for improving the workflow and on the job communication instead of feasting on pornography, chatting, and 6arab.com ( I should probably include blogging on the job as well
but lets say that blogging has the potential to be a positive social movement).
Yes, I do think that Kuwait is like a fallen butterfly, struggling to get up to fly again, but those busy ants are are tearing her to bits, and removing chunks off of her to store back in their anthole, while she weakly thrusts her legs in the air. Someone needs to shoo off all those ants and pick the beautiful butterfly up again; gently.
Yes, I think that we need a government full of progressive women who can nurture this country back to health. It’s going to take years to fix what all those men have done to this country.
(A small example is the attitude of those silly students in the Engineering College yesterday and their shameful fight- those are Tomorrow’s parliamentarians and ministers, eh?)
December 8, 2005 at 10:12 pm
Tantalize, excellent and well-written peice. With some editing and some cutting it would belong more on the Arab Times rather than a blogspot. Could be very useful for others. Think about it…
December 9, 2005 at 10:13 am
Jewaira: Informative suggestions and I’d agree with most of them. But, even if a teacher is radical and interestingly creative and gets the students’ attention, they’d still have a look and feel of defeat. The years they see in front of them overshadows the temporary classes/teachers they take. And it’s not just in the classrooms. The entire country is plagued with this. It’s a phenamenon really. Maybe if more competent women were put in strategic places, things would change. Maybe not! As you pointed out, even Kuwaiti women can be useless when given authority. And I don’t even think parenting and education would help much. Discipline seems to be taken lightly here. It’s the disease of pampering our children on one hand while negating them their own destinies on the other. Mix those with our weather, eating habits, outright sense of invincibility, reliance on foreigners to help with most menial and crucial work, an informal social class where many idiots have more than the deserving etc, and what do you get? Chaos.
What should be done in Kuwait is first re-invent the constitution or add worthwhile conditions that create a secular government, have a true democracy instead of a puppet crap, dissolve family/tribal control over many parts of governance, sideline religion as a choice instead of something inbedded in the country’s law, and truly open the consciousness of the country to any and all forms of ideals. Capitalism seems to be part of that new makeup already but we’ll have to wait and see what results out of it. There are many other variables I can discuss here but it’d take too much space and time.
December 9, 2005 at 10:16 am
Pretty great analysis.
Re: your female students. The same attitude resonates amongst many Muslim American women, be they first generation or recent immigrants. Even in the US, these girls are bound by traditions/customs of the “motherland” which, unfortunately, they feel they can not escape.
December 9, 2005 at 10:25 am
ZinZinQ8: Thank you. Arab Times. Yeah right! No thanks. I think blogging has a lot of potential and Kaleidoscope has been getting incredible hits since it started. Around 10,000 a month on average which doesn’t necessarily mean that many different readers but it means it’s increasing in traffic and international exposure as opposed to local more regulated and limited news feeds. There is no censorship on here. With Arab Times, there is. That’s the biggest difference! Kaleidoscope will also try to formulate a published version of writings taken from the best posts from here in the future and have them published as a paperback anthology as well as ebook. ;^)
Anonymous-comment: Interesting to know. I never was fully aware of that in the US. I thought many Muslim women gradually broke out of that mold. Could you elaborate on that more? I am very interested to know. Thank you.
December 9, 2005 at 4:48 pm
Tantalize: Thats the painful reality, unfortunatly the kind of people mentiond font read this.
routen in everything even in their believes! thats being a human .
December 9, 2005 at 7:36 pm
An excellent piece of self-criticism, and an insightful observation of what is wrong with our society.. Great work.
December 10, 2005 at 12:46 pm
Thanks guys.
December 10, 2005 at 2:50 pm
Tantalize,
I DEFINATELY agree with Jewaira on putting more women in leadership positions, and it’s not just because I’m a feminist. Women in Kuwait tend to be more constrained by morality than men, and for the most part, they tend to be more religious (يخافون من الله أكثر من الرجاجيل)and hard-working. Therefore, when given a position of responsibility, they will perform their duties with ethics and a sense of good for the country.
Furthermore, I am disturbed by your perpetual reference to Kuwaiti women as useless. Buddy, just because you and some of your friends have met the wrong kinds of women, it should not give you the conviction that we Kuwaiti women are money-hording, husband-cheating, lying Jezebels! Lighten up on the misogyny, will ya?!
And as for the Kuwaiti Constitution, it is a brilliant document, but we do not enforce its resolutions. Kuwait IS A SECULAR STATE. It is run by a civil constitution, not the Sharia. It’s the religious police that want to change the second resolution of the constitution to make the Sharia the only source of our laws. You have my whole-hearted vote on total separation between Mosque and State.
December 10, 2005 at 5:36 pm
Mushmushi: Excuse YOU? I wrote “Maybe if more competent women were put in strategic places, things would change. Maybe not! As you pointed out, even Kuwaiti women CAN be useless when given authority.”
That was my quote after Jewaira affirmed how Kuwaiti woman nowadays could be viewed as useless or incompetent. It seems your comprehension has been overtaken by resentment. Next time read carefully please before you lash out. You seem to love to take things slightly out of context whenever I write anything. I wonder why that is! You seem to make it personal! TRY to be objective or is that too hard for a ‘feminist’ to do?
;^)
December 10, 2005 at 6:03 pm
ur damn right its hard for a ‘feminist’ to do.. come to think of it, feminists cant do anything but talk about feminism .. (??)
that is: feminists find everything ‘hard’ to talk about, except when it comes to claiming how ‘easy’ it would be for them to make something better/right
feminists AND male-chauvinists need to get a life and quit treating the world as a competition show on LBC
December 10, 2005 at 7:51 pm
How interesting… I am learning a lot about your country. Clearly, oil money isn’t everything. I wouldn’t exchange the freedom of choice and the right to decide what to do with my life for any oil in the world.
My boss sometimes says this about oil rich countries: too much money, too soon, not ready.
And yay Temetwir, I SO agree!
December 10, 2005 at 10:31 pm
Qatar cat, don’t misunderstand our country and how we live because of this conversation. Things said on this site are regularly said in female and male gatherings (diwaniyat) across the country and we have no fear of secret police arresting us or any such thing. Take me for example, I am a Kuwaiti woman who has had the freedom to hold a position in a corporation in Kuwait as well as get educated and get my degrees abroad, living alone in an apartment. Never once did I feel that someone took away my freedom of choice and I am the only one with the right to decide what happens in my life. The only black dot on our freedom was the lack of suffrage and we got that right last May. So I think you have a totally mistaken idea of the country if you think it’s all about oil money (typical western attitude) while everything else is completely backward. I mean you hear people complaining about the government 24-7 in the states and no one says “the US is all about capitalism and everything else is all wrong and people lack freedom” Granted we have a lot to improve, but frankly, so does everyone.
December 10, 2005 at 11:17 pm
qatar cat,
the phrase “oil money” has been exhausted by everyone who is not living in the middle east ..
which is why i am shocked that u, living in qatar, would also use it .. i am sure that u are aware of the fact that the general public in the west think that ALL ‘rich families’ in the middle east have oil-related businesses .. which is as true as Bambi-the-flying-elephant (or was it Dumbo, or Dambi .. oh whatever i dunno)
ANYWAY, what tantalize shows in his piece is individualistic, in the sense that he speaks of individuals living in this part of the world, or our country, or “our society”
the rest, zinzinq8 has explained, and pretty darn well too..
again, qatar cat, i truly TRULY know how you would come at such an understanding, infact.. i EXPECT you to, simply because of the fact that some guys and girls have nothing better to do than just WHINE and act like kids instead of actually going out there and doing something for THEMSELVES, which will inevitably benefit society as a whole.. THAT is what those who bitch and whine about society being constrained and what have you should understand
cheers !
December 11, 2005 at 9:31 am
Dear Zinzinq and Temetwir! Thanks so much for your replies, frankly I was looking forward to some serious bashing after my comment, so thanks for being candid :^)
First and foremost - oil money. Exhausted phrase or not - oil money is oil money. Living in Qatar, reading Kaleidoscope and a lot of Kuwaiti (and other Gulfers) blogs I began to realise just HOW MUCH money there is in oil. When I see the mansions, and the cars, and the shops, the house servants, the citizens benefits, interest free loans, IPO shares, the trips to Europe and States few times a year - and not for select few, but for majority - please, PLEASE don’t tell me that Oil Money phrase is exhausted! When I see people who don’t have to lift a finger to make anything out of themselves because things tend to somehow end up being taken care of - don’t tell me that oil money phrase is exhausted.
Now - oil money is NOT BAD. And hey, I am neither being jealous nor accusing. Not even ignorant, believe it or not. OK so maybe a little jealous :^) But then again as I said, I wouldn’t trade my freedom of choice for any money in the world. To be fair to Zinzinq, I actually think that US is all about capitalism, and there is very little actual freedom there, and the human rights organisations turn a blind eye to whatever US seems to be happy with. So US is not a good example of freedom. Neither is any given country, I suppose, nobody anywhere is truly and totally free, and thanks goodness for that, or the world will fall into complete chaotic anarchy. Besides, I never thought that you can’t express your opinions in public in Kuwait.. have I said that anywhere?
So why did I write the comment I wrote? It was an answer to Tanta’s essay, that’s all. When I read about young people stuck in the way of life they neither choose nor support, when I read ALMOST ANY OTHER ESSAY that is posted here, from domestic abuse to arranged marriages to inability to prove yourself at work, to tribal influence and preferences - I would still say that no matter how much money one has, he or she still have to play by the rules and please everyone around them. Or at least make it look like it, which is even worse. See, I don’t have to do that, that’s why I think I enjoy a little more freedom than you do. Of course now I am just generalising, and being a little shallow, so please forgive me that.
I DO know that not everyone here has an oil pump at their backyard. I know plenty hardworking people who make their country proud. I also know that where I come from, things are far from perfect, and not even a steady oil stream could cure everything. Please take my comments as a response to one essay, and one essay only. I love Middle East, I live here, and with your help I learn more. Thank you.
December 12, 2005 at 10:35 pm
one word: perceptive.
what a post
bravo
December 12, 2005 at 11:49 pm
the11themuse: If you were refering to my post, THANK YOU and welcome here.
December 13, 2005 at 11:16 pm
yep.. i was refering to ur post.. who else would i be saying bravo to.. LOL..
December 31, 2005 at 3:12 am
1. Its good we don’t have a Qaat culture
2. My advise would be to get out of the government sector.. Right after graduating, i was interviewed at KU, and the head of the department where i wanted to teach told me “i know you, this culture is bad for you, go find a job in the private sector, i will not allow you to work here”.
It was the 1st time he’d ever seen me, but i happened to have gone to school with his younger brother, and he is/was very right. I do not see any of the defeatism you wrote about, although i know very well that it does exist.
3. Why do you call it “Self” defeatism?
February 15, 2008 at 3:09 am
Very well expressed. Your writing is superb. Keep writing.
February 22, 2008 at 9:49 am
interesting.. very interesting and true!
it’s one of your best posts..
if only people are more aware..
May 7, 2008 at 8:52 pm
Unfortunately, all what of the poster “Tantalize” said is true. People don’t have respect for anything they know that whenever they do something wrong” WASTA always solves the problem.”
Can I ask you something,” what’s “liban” got to with this?”
This is absolutely wonderful; it’s a piece of art.